Reb
Elyakim Shlessinger once asked the Brisker Rav why his wife’s grandfather, Reb
Yaakov Rosenheim, changed his views on Zionism in his old age. Throughout the
pre-State era, Rosenheim constantly reiterated the decision of the Moetzes
Gedolei Hatorah, that Jewish law did not permit the founding of the proposed
Jewish state. We must see the planned state as a great misfortune for Jewry,
Rosenheim wrote in a 1944 letter to Rabbi Chaim Bloch. But after the State was
founded and the Agudah activists, without the benefit of any explicit ruling
from the Moetzes, began to participate in the government, Rosenheim began to
speak more positively of it. “I will tell you something the Kotzker said,” said
the Brisker Rav. “The Torah says that Yisro heard about the Exodus and came to
join the Jewish people in the desert. Rashi explains that he heard about the
parting of the Red Sea and the war with Amalek. Why did Rashi select these two
things? So the Kotzker said, Yisro heard about the great miracle of the Red Sea
and he wanted to be a Jew, but that didn’t mean he had to come out to the
desert to join the Jewish people. He could have waited till they entered the
Land of Canaan and joined them there. But then he heard about Amalek’s attack.
The Amalekites had also heard about the miracles, and yet they continued to be
wicked. How could that be? Because Amalek didn’t have a rebbe. One must never
rely on his own reading of events; one must always have a rebbe. In that case,
said Yisro, I must come to be with the Jewish people right away. Your
grandfather,” the Brisker Rav concluded, “in his younger years, always had a
rebbe. He listened to my father and to the Chofetz Chaim. The Gedolim then were
all much older than he. But I and the other Rabbanim of today are closer to his
age. In his formative years, we were all mere yungerleit, and that is the
permanent picture he formed of us. Now, in his old age, when all his rebbes are
gone, it’s no wonder that he can’t see us as his rebbes. So he is left without
a rebbe. And without a rebbe, it is impossible to stay on the proper path.” (Mikatowitz Ad Hei B’Iyar, p. 343) https://torahjews.org/2023/11/24/parsha-pearls-parshas-yisro/